Study for Man the Creator, circa 1932
Unframed (ref: 2971)
Mural scheme for the Rockefeller Center, New York,
Oil on canvas,
108 x 72 in. (274.3 x 182.9 cm.)
Picasso, and Matisse were originally offered this 1932 commission for the Rockefeller Centre murals, before Brangwyn, the Spanish artist José Maria Sert and the Mexican, Diego Rivera were subsequently appointed to carry out the scheme. Critics complained that American artists should have been chosen for the prestigious work. Further controversy followed in May 1933 Rivera was prevented from ﬁnishing his mural when it was discovered that he had included a portrait of Lenin, and sympathizers of the artist clashed with police outside the building. The authorities also objected to the bright colours of the panel (Sert and Brangwyn had both agreed to paint monochrome works) and the mural was taken down and replaced by a new mural by Sert.
In September 1933, Brangwyn himself faced controversy. Ofﬁcials from
the Rockefeller Center objected to the ﬁgure of Christ being included in
the fourth panel, representing the Sermon on the Mount. Raymond M Hood,
one of the architects of the Center, explained that, ‘some people here
felt that it would not be ﬁtting to put the ﬁgure of Christ in a
business building.They thought that might be too strong a representation
of an individual religion’.
Brangwyn's paintings remain in situ: four large murals placed on the South corridor elevator banks of the RCA building each measuring 17x25ft and divided as follows: Man labouring painfully with his own hands; living precariously and adventurously, with courage, fortitude and the indomitable will to survive; Man the creator and master of the tool. Strengthening the foundations and multiplying the comforts of his abiding place; Man the master and servant of the machine, harnessing to his will the forces of the material world, mechanizing labour, and adding thereto the promise of leisure; Man’s ultimate destiny depends not on whether he can learn new lessons or make new discoveries and conquests, but on his acceptance of the lesson taught him close upon two thousand years ago.
Not more than 70–75% of the canvas was to be painted and lettering was to be included.
We are grateful to Dr Libby Horner for assistance. This study will appear as M1110 in her forthcoming catalogue raisonne.